RatedOtels.Com

Hotel in Commack

Commack Inn

5.9/10 Fabulous | 96 Reviews
2.5-star hotel
Commack Inn

2231 Jericho Turnpike | Commack, NEW YORK 11725, US View Map

5.9 Fabulous 96 Reviews View Map
1 / 20

Rooms

Real-time rates, no booking fees, instant confirmation

Select dates to see prices

Double Room

34.84 m²

Deluxe King Room

34.84 m²

Deluxe King Room

34.84 m²

Deluxe Queen Room

34.84 m²

Deluxe Queen Room

34.84 m²

Deluxe King Room

34.84 m²

Key facts

Property type
2.5-star hotel
Address
2231 Jericho Turnpike | Commack, NEW YORK 11725, US
Nearby landmark
Sunshine Acres Park · 0.3 mi (straight line)
Nearest airport
Republic Airport (FRG) · 10 mi (straight line)
Check-in / check-out
16:00 / 11:30
Top facilities
Free parking, Free Wi-Fi, Pet-friendly rooms, 24-hour front desk
Rooms
30
Guest score
5.9/10 from 96 reviews

Overview

Highlights, description and the facilities guests use most.

  • Front desk [24-hour]
  • Great for activities
  • Located in heart of Commack
  • Excellent room comfort & quality

About Commack Inn

Commack Inn is located in Commack, within 22 miles of Nassau Veterans Memorial Coliseum and 27 miles of Belmont Park Race Track. This 4-star hotel offers a 24-hour front desk, an ATM and free WiFi. Jones Beach is 30 miles from the hotel, while Nikon Theater is 30 miles away.

Long Island MacArthur Airport is 11 miles from the property.

Top Amenities

  • Free parking
  • Free Wi-Fi
  • Pet-friendly

Location

2231 Jericho Turnpike | Commack, NEW YORK 11725, US

View Map© Mapbox © OpenStreetMap

View Map

Services & Facilities

38 amenities in 12 categories.

Accessibility

2 items
  • Facilities for disabled guests available
  • Wheelchair accessible

Activities & Things to do

1 item
  • Bowling

Food & Drinks

3 items
  • Individually-wrapped food options
  • Food delivery
  • Vending machine

General

8 items
  • 24-Hour Front Desk
  • Non-smoking property
  • Private check-in/check-out
  • Pets allowed (charges may apply)
  • Air conditioning in public area
  • Heating in public area
View All 8
  • Exterior Corridor
  • Non-Smoking Rooms Available

Languages spoken

5 items
  • Burmese
  • English
  • Chinese [Mandarin]
  • Hindi
  • Spanish

Media & Technology

1 item
  • Free Wi-Fi
Show 6 more categories

Outdoor Recreation

2 items
  • Golf Course
  • Mini golf

Room Amenities

4 items
  • Cleaning products available
  • Smoke alarms
  • Fire extinguishers
  • Soundproof rooms available

Security

3 items
  • CCTV security in common areas
  • Safety chain and/or latch on doors available
  • 24-hour security

Services and Conveniences

4 items
  • Daily Housekeeping
  • Designated Smoking Area
  • Invoices
  • ATM or cash withdraw on site

Transportation

2 items
  • Free Parking
  • On-site parking

Health Services

3 items
  • First aid kit available
  • Access to health care professionals
  • Temperature check for guests and staff

Policies

Check-in, check-out and house rules.

  • Check-in
    16:00
  • Check-out
    11:30
  • Front desk [24-hour]

FAQs about Commack Inn

What are the check-in and check-out times at Commack Inn?
Check-in is from 16:00 and check-out is until 11:30.
What is there to see near Commack Inn?
Places nearby include Sunshine Acres Park, Burr-Winkle Park and Wicks Park.
Which facilities does Commack Inn have?
Facilities include free parking, free Wi-Fi, pet-friendly rooms and 24-hour front desk.
Is parking available?
Yes, free parking is available.
Are pets allowed?
Yes, pets are allowed (charges may apply).
How far is Commack Inn from the airport?
Republic Airport (FRG) is about 10 mi away in a straight line.

Guest Score and Reviews

Loved by Guests, Trusted for Excellence

5.9 /10
Fabulous
Based on 96 Reviews
G
Gurshanpal
Solo Traveler · Sep 26, 2024
10.0

Exceptional

I
Inga
Group Traveler · May 22, 2025
10.0

Liked: Clean, safe, nice stuff, complimentary coffee in the morning Disliked: Too bright in the room for me and I forgot my mask for sleeping

R
Ruth
Solo Traveler · May 26, 2025
1.0

Liked: The was place was so duty. I couldn't not sleep on the duty place like that , I wasted my money I couldn't not sleep on the duty place like that , I have to make reservation to another place Disliked: I wasted my money ? duty place ever ?

M
Munn
Couple · Jul 16, 2025
1.0

For your next STD stay @ The Commack Motor Inn Liked: I can't believe booking.YUCK even lists this property! Disliked: This hourly motel has not seen an update since the early 70s, if ever. Built in cassette and 8-track player, mirrored walls & ceiling, cigarette burn marks on the linen. The room lo

View All Reviews
I
Iryna
Couple · Jul 17, 2025
1.0

Avoid to stay in that proparty. Dirtiest place you can find. Liked: 0 Disliked: Worst property I ever had experience to stay. Such a dirty disgusting place and old, with sockets not even able to use. I would never expect it to be that bad. For the price of $200???? It’s not worth $10. I fell to leav

S
Sylvia
Solo Traveler · Aug 4, 2025
6.0

A mixed bag, but they are trying Liked: While the outside of the Inn looks very dated, the owner is systematically renovating the rooms, so when I got into the room, I was pleasantly surprised that the room was freshly painted, clean and the bathroom was pretty nice. Disliked: There were some proble

M
Milena
Couple · Aug 12, 2025
1.0

Never stay there Liked: Nothing Disliked: Everything

P
Paul
Couple · Aug 17, 2025
9.0

Liked: Else around a lot of restaurants which we was accessible to and to the highway for us to return back home Disliked: The bathroom seat was broken at night there's a lot of commotion that was going on don't know what it was but it was making it hard for us to really sleep people with I think a

E
Erik
Solo Traveler · Aug 23, 2025
2.0

Do not go there it is just gross Liked: The place was just absolutely disgusting it smelled and there were bugs all over the place. One of the dirtiest hotels that I've ever slept it was just disgusting

J
Joann
Solo Traveler · Sep 8, 2025
6.0

Liked: The room was clean and the staff friendly. Disliked: The room was cold. Had to turn air conditioner totally off to get somewhat comfortable. The shower was so so.

J
JOHN
Solo Traveler · Sep 13, 2025
10.0

SATISFIED

P
Patrizia
Solo Traveler · Oct 3, 2025
4.0

Liked: I was volunteering at the Ryder Cup. The inn was close. Room was OK barely clean enough. Bed was fairly comfortable. Good location close to a lot of good restaurants and central to much of Long Island. Disliked: It's kind of a sketchy place. Carpet in hallway had not been replaced in ma

M
Marie F.
Couple · Oct 12, 2025
2.0

Liked: Nothing Disliked: i paid for a non smoking and they gave me a smoking room. It was a bad experience.

J
Jabadari
Couple · Oct 13, 2025
1.0

Most worse experience in my life Liked: Theres nothng i gonna like about this Hostel!!! Disliked: Everything dirty like hell, horrible staff

K
Kimberly
Couple · Oct 13, 2025
9.0

Overall a very positive experience, I would definitely stay there again. Liked: I made a mistake and was put in a smoking room. Disliked: The guest next door were partying until 3 am and back at it at 6:30 am. I should have gone to the office but did not. The room has been refurbished and was very n

W
Wilkinson
Couple · Oct 13, 2025
10.0

Liked: Clean and up to date decent price great staff Disliked: Bed too high room small

S
Smith
Solo Traveler · Oct 14, 2025
2.0

Liked: I didn’t have breakfast

G
George
Solo Traveler · Oct 30, 2025
9.0

Excellent Liked: Everything Disliked: Nothing

B
bryant
Couple · Nov 9, 2025
3.0

Didn’t sleep all night. The call girls went back and forth Liked: Nothing Disliked: We had a dirty bloody mattress… looks like there was a killing on it

D
Danais
Couple · Nov 17, 2025
1.0

Disappointed, worst place I ever stayed in my entire traveling career Liked: People smoking in the room, place is scary, they almost took some expensive stuff I accidentally forgot in the etc… Disliked: ??????

F
Fiona
Solo Traveler · Dec 12, 2025
1.0

Liked: FILTHY FILTHY FILTHY Disliked: FILTHY FILTHY FILTHY

J
Jason
Couple · Dec 14, 2025
2.0

Dirty, gross and not worth it Liked: Nothing Disliked: The place is dirty, this property should be shut down due to a lot of health issues

D
Deiby
Solo Traveler · Jan 19, 2026
8.0

Comfortable, very Clean and convenient place to stay Liked: Renovated & clean, on a main road in the center of town. Disliked: Very small room size.

S
Stevie
Couple · Jan 20, 2026
1.0

Terrible customer service Disliked: Was charged an extra 40$ for requesting a whirlpool room, even though I booked a deluxe king. Was told I couldn’t get a receipt, then wouldn’t let me get the whirlpool room

W
Wheeler
Solo Traveler · May 16, 2026
8.0

Liked: Updated room Disliked: Staff at the front door checking in

Things to do in Commack

Mattituck New York Guided Farm and Wine Country Bike Tour

4.9 (42 reviews)5.5 hours

Book this tour

Private Beach Fire Montauk

5.0 (12 reviews)3 hours

Book this experience

Private Yacht Charter in The Hamptons, Montauk or Sag Harbor

5.0 (10 reviews)2–4 hours

Book this tour

Southold Bay Oyster Farm Tour

5.0 (6 reviews)2–3 hours

Book this tour

Captain Steve's Sailing Experience on Long Island

5.0 (6 reviews)2 hours

Book this experience

Guided Farm and Wine Country Bike Tour in Mattituck NY

5.0 (5 reviews)5.5 hours

Book this tour

Boat or Yacht Rental in Sag Harbor, The Hamptons, or Monatauk

5.0 (4 reviews)4 hours

Book this experience

Photos

Commack Inn

5.9/10 Fabulous · 96 Reviews
Commack Inn